‘From the river to the sea’: Why a Palestinian rallying cry ignites dispute

People, including one holding up a sign that reads, “From the river to the sea,” chant slogans under Palestinian flags during a “Freedom for Palestine” protest that drew thousands of participants in Berlin on Nov. 4 in Berlin. (Sean Gallup/Getty Images)

A decades-old rallying cry for Palestinian nationalist aspirations has reached a new, broad audience among opponents of Israel’s military campaign in the Gaza Strip.

At protests and on social media, activists and pro-Palestinian demonstrators have used the phrase “from the river to the sea” to express support for the cause of Gaza and Palestinians in the Israeli-occupied West Bank. The slogan refers to the territory between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea — which includes the state of Israel — and is often followed by a second clause: “Palestine will be free.”

LEBANON

SYRIA

GOLAN

HEIGHTS

Annexed by

Israel in

1981, not

internationally

recognized

Haifa

Sea of

Galilee

Med.

Sea

Jordan

River

WEST

BANK

Tel Aviv

Amman

Ramallah

Jerusalem

Dead

Sea

Gaza City

GAZA

ISRAEL

JORDAN

EGYPT

THE WASHINGTON POST

LEBANON

SYRIA

GOLAN

HEIGHTS

Annexed by Israel

in 1981, not

internationally

recognized

Haifa

Sea of

Galilee

Mediterranean

Sea

Jordan River

WEST BANK

Tel Aviv

Amman

Ramallah

Jerusalem

Dead

Sea

Gaza City

GAZA

ISRAEL

JORDAN

EGYPT

THE WASHINGTON POST

LEBANON

SYRIA

GOLAN

HEIGHTS

Annexed by Israel in

1981, not internationally

recognized

Haifa

Sea of

Galilee

Mediterranean

Sea

Jordan River

WEST BANK

Tel Aviv

Amman

Ramallah

Jerusalem

Gaza City

Dead

Sea

GAZA

ISRAEL

JORDAN

EGYPT

THE WASHINGTON POST

Some people have interpreted the phrase as a call to eradicate Israel and critics, including some Jewish American organizations, who say that it constitutes antisemitic speech. A rise in antisemitic attacks in the United States and Europe since the start of the war has contributed to the unease.

Pro-Palestinian activists say the controversy over the phrase, which is encompassing enough to express a range of visions, serves to silence dissent over Israel’s assault on Hamas in Gaza, launched in response to the Hamas attack on Israeli communities last month.

Last week, the House of Representatives censured Rep. Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.), the only Palestinian American member of Congress, for her remarks about the conflict and a video she posted on social media of protesters chanting the slogan.

Here’s what to know about the origins of the phrase, its connotations and the controversy it has caused.